Blackmail in Game Theory, Aftermath

Aftermath, Lesath Lestrange:

Lesath tapped his foot nervously, and waited for the staircase to theHeadmistress’s office to present itself to him. A disgusted-looking ProfessorSlughorn had instructed him to report to the Headmistress at once. Peoplelooked disgusted at him all the time, but given the context, Lesath’s heartwas pounding, and his mind was racing through every bad thing he had everdone, wondering which one he would be expelled for – or if perhaps he wasoverestimating the severity of the situation, and he would simply be suspendedor killed. The staircase turned to face him, and he ascended to meet his fate.First she spoke something inaudible into her desk, and then she turned toconfront Lesath directly.

“Mr. Lestrange?” said the Headmistress. “Please sit down.” She sounded calmand sympathetic, and not in the fake-calm manner of someone planning to expel,suspend, or kill you. So Lesath sat down, and kept an open mind, and barelyeven wondered what was going on. “I am afraid that this conversation will notbe pleasant, but given the wider circumstances occurring at the school, thatis frankly a relief.”

“What is it,” muttered Lesath; he was still fairly certain he was in trouble.

“You have turned out to be our first false alarm,” said the Headmistress, “andquite an alarm, too. Your case has demonstrated a rather severe flaw in myinitial plan, which is that, while children are certainly not to be ignored,immaturity is considered a character flaw for a reason. You see…” She paused,and considered how to relate the recent events to him. “After I announced tothe school that, to find the ‘Heir of Slytherin’, anything suspicious shouldbe reported without question, I was immediately inundated with reports aboutyou. Nearly all of them from girls, most all of them from younger Slytheringirls.”

“Who?” said Lesath. He was trying and failing to hide his anger.

“For the sake of obvious privacy concerns, I am not at liberty to say,” saidthe Headmistress. “Now, of course I followed up on these reports, asking forspecifics on what about you they considered suspicious. A few of them lied,providing half-baked and easily falsified stories designed to incriminate youas the Heir; they will be disciplined for malicious abuse of Hogwartsresources. But most of them simply described your general behavior anddemeanor as of late. They did not seem to understand that your behavior issuggestive not of a secret Dark Lord, but of an awkward teenage boy who isout-of-touch with social norms and standards. In short, the system I createdzeroed in on you not because you were a reasonable suspect, but because youwere unpopular.” Lesath looked back and forth, deep in thought, and theHeadmistress stopped because she could see that he needed to process this,though she was at a natural stopping point anyway.

“So why are you telling me all of this?” said Lesath.

“Because,” said the Headmistress, starting slowly, “though your accusers didnot choose the correct venue to put forward their concerns, we are still gladto have found out, because Hogwarts does not tolerate inappropriate orboundary-violating behavior, particularly of a sexual nature. This is yourfirst warning. If the behavior continues, you will be given detention, andultimately will face criminal charges, suspension, or even expulsion if itgoes further. Is this understood?”

“Yes,” said Lesath.

“If you feel you need to learn more about social boundaries and norms, I coulddirect you to a professional-”

“No,” said Lesath, and the Headmistress frowned.

“I advise that you don’t bother anyone anytime soon,” said the Headmistress.“Now, go. Off. It’s bad enough dealing with the Heir of Slytherin andSlytherin’s Monster without awkward teenage boys too.” She halfheartedlysmiled, and Lesath did, too, and left. Girls were so weird. Perhaps hewouldn’t find romance until after graduation.

What long years those would be.


Aftermath, Draco Malfoy:

“Hello, Harry,” said Draco.

“Hello, Draco,” said Harry. He seemed oddly uncomfortable to be talking toDraco. First, Harry apparently hadn’t been very well-trained in the Slytherinarts, if he was this bad at hiding his discomfort. Second, his discomfort wasvery disconcerting. Draco thought he had chose to stop talking to Harry, notthe other way around.

“I’ve wanted to talk to you, about… what’s been going on,” said Draco. “Do youhave time now, or are you busy?” Harry groaned, and instinctively reached forhis pocket.

“I always have time,” said Harry, and they found a quiet space with a bench.Harry cast as many anti-eavesdropping spells as he considered appropriate.

“Good,” said Draco. “We haven’t talked in quite some time. How have you been?What have you been up to?”

“I’ve been fine,” said Harry, “and I’ve mostly been up to official businessI’m afraid I can’t tell you, or nearly any of my classmates, about.”

“Of course,” said Draco, concealing his irritation entirely. “Do you have anymore idea than the rest of us what’s going on, who’s causing trouble?”

“Perhaps a bit, but not much,” said Harry. “If we’d caught the perpetrator,they would already be publicly known and behind bars. The only alternate caseI can see is if we’d caught them but they’d escaped, in which case theiridentity and that we’d caught them would still be publicly known. The problemis that we don’t even have a testable hypothesis, Draco. We don’t even haveany suspects. We had a couple of suspects at first, but they were very quicklycleared.” Draco frowned.

“You’re a Parselmouth, Potter,” said Draco.

“Yes, I know,” said Harry. “That’s why I was one of the initial suspects. ButI can’t be the person doing this, Draco. I have no interest whatsoever inbreaking the Line of Merlin Unbroken or the Interdict of Merlin. In fact,there are reasons I can’t tell you about that I believe breaking either ofthose would be a very bad thing.”

“I don’t mean to cast aspersions on you,” said Draco, “but couldn’t thatsimply mean that you’re the perpetrator and you’re playing one level higher?Trying to drum up pro-Interdict sentiment, to protect it?” Harry swallowed.

“No one’s thought of that as far as I know,” said Harry. “I’d barely evenconsidered that. It’s technically plausible, but there are Muggles who believein such plans, they’re known as ‘false flag operations’, and the Muggles whoare most inclined to believe that they’ve happened are generally extremelycognitively deficient, but I can’t think of any particular reason thatcouldn’t be what happened here. It couldn’t have been me, though; as far as Iknow, there is no nearby risk of the Line of Merlin Unbroken breaking. It’sjust not something that could be done. Whoever is causing all of this troubleis misinformed about how the Line works, either because they’re demanding wedestroy it, which is impossible, or because they’re trying to protect it frombeing destroyed, which is also impossible.”

“Hmm,” said Draco. “Whoever did this is still definitely a Parselmouth. Do youknow any other Parselmouths around the school? Parselmouths are supposed toknow each other.”

“I was only aware of one other Parselmouth at the school,” said Harry, “andshe was also one of the initial suspects.”

“No, Granger-” started Draco. Harry smiled. “It is Granger, isn’t it?”

“You are very perceptive, Draco,” said Harry. “Don’t let her know you know,though; she would kill me.”

“Of course,” said Draco.

“And she was aware of one other Parselmouth at the school,” said Harry, “whoto the best of my knowledge was investigated and cleared when it wasdetermined he didn’t even know he was a Parselmouth before.”

“So there’s a secret Parselmouth at school,” said Draco. “Either a student ora teacher. Lockhart-”

“Maybe,” said Harry. “I have an alternate theory, though. Voldemort was aParselmouth, you know.”

“No…” said Draco, not because he didn’t know, but because he could alreadytell that Potter was leading into some deeper horrifying revelation.

“Voldemort might not be completely dead,” said Harry. “I believe, based onevidence, that he has objects lying around in random places, by which he mightpossess someone – a teacher or student at Hogwarts, for example. And then,theoretically, he could speak in Parseltongue, and open the Chamber.” Dracostared into space for something like twenty seconds, with the most appalledlook on his face. “What? What is it?”

“I think I might have-” Draco’s voice went out, and Harry shot up out of hisseat.

“What happened?” asked Harry, with much more force, and he directed Draco tostand up and walk with him – and quickly, too.

“IhadamysteriousobjectlefttomebymyfatherthatcouldwriteandthinklikeahumananditconvincedmetogiveittoanotherHogwartsstudentGinnyWeasleyandohmyGodisshegoingtobeokay?” said Draco, keeping up with Harry.

“Follow me,” said Harry.

“Are we going to find Ginny, and save her?” said Draco.

“Probably,” said Harry, “but we’re talking to the Headmistress first. I wantyou to tell her everything you know.”

“Okay,” said Draco, “but what if the Headmistress can’t do anything?”

“Then we won’t be able to do anything either,” said Harry.

“Will we be able to save her?” said Draco. “Will she be punished?”

“Assuming that your suggested explanation is the correct one,” said Harry,“which seems like the Occam’s Razor solution at the moment, then we willalmost certainly be able to save her, and she will almost certainly not bepunished. Nobody is held accountable for things they do while they’repossessed. Like-” Harry stopped himself from saying something, and Dracowondered what it could possibly be. Here was the entrance to theHeadmistress’s room. Harry approached the password-receiving gargoyle, but wasinterrupted by-

“Harry! Draco!” said Professor Lockhart. “What are you doing here?”

“No time, Professor,” said Harry, and he whispered something Draco somehowmanaged not to hear at all. Absolutely nothing happened, and Harry repeatedwhatever he’d just said. “Why isn’t it working?”

“The Headmistress is in a particularly private meeting with a student,” saidProfessor Lockhart, “and I advise that you return in ten minutes.”

“But this is more important!” said Harry. “This is an emergency!” A suspicionwas beginning to sneak up on Draco, and Professor Lockhart raised an eyebrow.

“Really?” said the Professor. “What kind of emergency?”


Aftermath, Cho Chang:

There is a fountain filled with blood, drawn from Immanuel’s veins, andsinners plunge beneath that flood, lose all their guilty stains.

As Cedric’s body was lowered into the cold and lonely ground, Cho Chang failedto hear the words of the hymn being sung. It was just as well; she was not anadherent of the religion in which the words had significance. Nor, for thatmatter, was the majority of the choir singing it. It was just a tradition, afuneral tradition, an ancient thing that goes unquestioned and largely unseen,a specific type of prior that can be particularly difficult to root out. Itwas simply how the funeral was supposed to be.

But this funeral was not supposed to be at all. It wasn’t supposed to go likethis. Cho Chang was supposed to become a widow – or create a widower – aroundage 200. She wasn’t supposed to be mourning the love of her life at 13. Ofcourse, Cedric wasn’t truly the love of Cho’s life – apparently. Because shewould live much, much longer. Wouldn’t she? Actually, with the advent of thePeverell Family Hospital, she never had to die at all. …Cedric had never hadto die at all. They could have truly been together forever, exploring thestars in some magic craft of Harry’s. Why had that been ripped away from her?Why had Cedric been ripped away from everybody? Cho tried to feel hatred oranger at whoever had done this, but she was not capable; her grief was toooverwhelming of an emotion.

“When he laughed, you swore you’d never cry again,” Cho had told a reporter,through tears, before the funeral had begun. But Cho didn’t want to talk toanyone, least of all the press. She just wanted to think, but that was toohard; depression releases chemicals in the brain that inhibit regularthinking. So she just wanted to take in the world around her, and judge it.Nobody else at the funeral looked nearly sad enough. They all looked sad, justnot enough. It was as if they had all gotten so used to carrying out funeralsthat they were simply playing a role, and it had slipped their minds howgenuinely awful it all was, particularly now, now that we were all so close tothe finish line that the Philosopher’s Stone represented.

The Malfoys were sitting next to the Weasleys. The Malfoys were sitting nextto the Weasleys. The Malfoys didn’t even seem bothered by that. Had Cedric’sdeath truly shaken everybody up that much? That made Cho feel ever soinfinitesimally better. Draco Malfoy had lost his father last year, hadn’t he?Cho supposed she would find no shortage at Hogwarts of people who hadexperienced death. She still felt particularly alone.

It occurred to Cho that with the advent of the Philosopher’s Stone, there wasabsolutely no reason that anything like this should ever happen again.Accidents and murders? If anything short of immediately or quickly lethaldamage could be recovered, why wouldn’t you minimize risk as much as possible?There was no reason whatsoever that this couldn’t or shouldn’t be Cho’s lastfuneral. There was no reason whatsoever that this couldn’t or shouldn’t be thelast funeral in the world.

Cho had not been able to cast her Patronus, not since she had learned ofCedric’s death in certain terms. She was still recovering from her mentalreeling, and would not return to Hogwarts until January, still in miserablecondition. But it was that thought – the last funeral in the world – thatwould allow Cho to cast a different Patronus, several years afterwards.


Aftermath, Tom Riddle Prime:

The man who could not even remember his own name drifted through space, amidstPlatonic forms and timeless physics. He was and was not a gemstone, and so hecould and could not think – like a sleeping man, he was vaguely aware ofeverything around him, but he could not hold onto any of it. He could notthink, and he could not remember; he could not even long for the day he wouldbe free. He could only perceive and dream, like an Elder God that had oncebeen human and would someday be human once more.

“Headmistress,” said the boy, who was wearing the man who could not evenremember his own name, “I am becoming increasingly certain of one of my firsthypotheses, that this is the work of a horcrux of Voldemort.”

“I thought he was on your person,” said the older woman, and she gestured atthe finger that held the man. “And in this state, he could not access hishorcruxes.”

“He is,” said the boy, “and he can’t, but he made two types of horcruxes. Wehave been referring to the more advanced type. He also made a more primitivekind, with entirely different properties.” The older woman frowned.

“Properties that you suspect leave them dangerous,” said the older woman.

“Yes, absolutely,” said the boy. “Because instead of being connected to themain Voldemort, and therefore being vulnerable to attacks on Voldemort’s mainbody that also influence his soul, they contain an entirely independent copyof Voldemort, diverging from the original at the moment that they’re created.”The older woman grew a look of horror. “The only possible complicating factor,which is completely ambiguous, is that I was under the impression Voldemorthad destroyed many, most, or all of them himself, when he moved onto the moreadvanced sort of horcrux.”

“No,” said the older woman. “Not Tom Riddle. He always had some sort of backupplan in mind in case we defeated his first intentions.”

“Speaking of the original Tom Riddle, though,” said the boy, “I’d prefer thatwe not keep him on my person anymore. Even with all of the extra securitymeasures you’ve placed on Hermione and me, I feel the risk is too large,particularly if I’m correct that it’s another Tom Riddle doing all of this.”He removed the gemstone that was the man.

“If not on your person, then where?” asked the older woman, and she visiblypanicked and squirmed away. “The Transfiguration must be sustained.”

“Yes,” said the boy, “but it doesn’t need to be sustained by myself. It wasfoolish to assume it did in the first place; I’m too important to put anotheregg in my basket like that. It should preferably be sustained by someonetrusted off-campus. I’d suggest Moody, but he seems a bit obvious. How about ahigh-ranking Unspeakable? I can’t imagine any Dark Lord catching Bode off-guard…”


Subscribe to the weekly digest of our best stories!

If you like this site, you should check out my other projects:


Login to leave a comment.
Success! Thank you for subscribing!